| 1998 (P) | | 10-4 | | Lost 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 1999 (P) | | 8-6 | | Lost 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 2000 (P) | | 9-5 | | Lost 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2000 (K) | | 13-1 | | Lost 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2001 (K) | | 11-3 | | Lost 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2001 (C) | | 7-7 | | Lost 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 2001 (P) | | 6-8 | | Last in division, missed playoffs |
| 2002 (P) | | 6-8 | | Last in division, missed playoffs |
| 2002 (K) | | 9-5 | | Won Super Bowl |
| 2003 (P) | | 7-7 | | Won Super Bowl |
| 2003 (K) | | 9-5 | | Lost in Super Bowl |
| 2004 (P) | | 10-4 | | Lost in 1st round of playoffs (to me) |
| 2004 (K) | | 9-5 | | Lost in 2nd round of playoffs |
| 2005 (P) | | 9-7 | | Lost in Super Bowl |
| 2005 (K) | | 9-5 | | Lost in 1st round of playoffs |
| 2006 (P) | | 7-6 | | Lost in 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2006 (K) | | 9-4 | | Lost in 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2007 (P) | | 5-8 | | Missed Playoffs |
| 2007 (K) | | 8-5 | | Won KEEPER Super Bowl vs Comeback Colts |
| 2008 (P) | | 9-4 | | Lost in 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 2008 (K) | | 11-2 | | Lost in 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 2009 (P) | | 8-5 | | Lost in Super Bowl vs Meathooks |
| 2009 (K) | | 7-6 | | Lost in 1st Rd of Playoffs |
| 2010 (P) | | 8-5 | | Lost in 2nd Rd of Playoffs |
| 2010 (K) | | 6-7 | | Missed Playoffs |
| 2011 (P) | | 6-7 | | Missed Playoffs |
| 2011 (K) | | 9-4 | | Lost in KEEPER Super Bowl to Comeback Colts |
| 2012 (P) | | 9-3-1 | | Won Super Bowl vs Grim Reapers |
| 2012 (K) | | 5-8 | | Missed Playoffs |
| 2013 (P) | | 9-4 | | Lost in 1st Rd of Playoffs to Rob Digiosio |
| 2013 (K) | | 7-6 | | Lost in 2nd Rd of Playoffs to Jeff Girard |
